![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Teri Adams, Head of Independence Hall Tea Party and School Voucher Activist:
Our ultimate goal is to shut down public schools and have private schools only, eventually returning responsibility for payment to parents and private charities. It’s going to happen piecemeal and not overnight. It took us years to get into this mess and it’s going to take years to get out of it.
In other words, Adams would like education to be, along with medical care, available only to those who can pony up the cash for it.
The article I’ve linked to includes a few quotes from people speculating about what drives the American right’s hostility towards public education. The ban on teacher-led prayer is invoked, along with the mercenary desire to funnel the money now paid into public schools into private hands.
I suspect it’s much more simple than that. Without universal education, the far right wouldn’t have to contend with so many pesky arguments about the facts of history, math, science, etc.
Crossposted from Thoughtcrimes
*
(no subject)
Date: 16/7/11 21:39 (UTC)If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 21:43 (UTC)While critics tend to rely on the three-decades long decline of the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) to document the dumbing down of American education, more alarming is our performance against the students of other industrialized countries. By virtually every measure of achievement, American students lag far behind their counterparts in both Asia and Europe, especially in math and science. Moreover, the evidence suggests that they are falling farther and farther behind. As educational researcher Harold Stevenson notes, although "the U.S. is among the countries expending the highest proportion of their gross national product on education, our elementary school and secondary school students never place above the median in comparative studies of academic achievement."
Part of the reason is that neither our schools nor our students spend very much time at it. The National Education Commission on Time and Learning found that most American students spend less than half their day actually studying academic subjects. The commission's two-year study found that American students spent only about 41 percent of the school day on basic academics. Their schedules jammed with course work in self-esteem, personal safety, AIDS education, family life, consumer training, driver's ed, holistic health, and gym, the typical American high school student spends only 1,460 hours on subjects like math, science, and history during their four years in high schools. Meanwhile, their counterparts in Japan will spend 3,170 hours on basic subjects, students in France will spend 3,280 on academics, while students in Germany will spend 3,528 hours studying such subjects - nearly three times the hours devoted in American schools.
By some estimates, teachers in Japan give elementary students three times as much homework as American children are given by their teachers, while teachers in Taipei give their students seven times as much homework as children in Minneapolis. By fifth grade, children in Minneapolis are getting slightly more than four hours a week in homework, while fifth graders in Japan get six hours and students in Taipei, thirteen hours.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0312134746/foundatfortruthi
Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 21:47 (UTC)Again, please cite your source for such a claim.
Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 21:54 (UTC)http://www.intellectualtakeout.org/library/literacy/functional-illiteracy-and-literacy-problems-america
The U.S. Department of Education (USDOE) estimates that functional illiteracy affects 24 million Americans. Educator Chester E. Finn, Jr. states, “Just five percent of seventeen-year-old high school students can read well enough to understand and use information found in technical materials, literary essays, and historical documents. Barely six percent of them can solve multi-step math problems and use basic algebra." ("A Nation Still At Risk," Chester Finn, May 1989, p. 18). http://www.useless-knowledge.com/1234/aug/article321.html
The USDOE estimates 40 million Americans 16 years of age and older possess what are called “Level 1” reading and writing skills. This means they can sign their name, but can't understand such basics as the instructions for programming a VCR, reading a map, or accurately fill out an application for a Social Security card.
Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:16 (UTC)I am a teacher of English. I've encountered students who the public school system have failed who struggle with the basics of English grammar, but they are by no means the majority of students. And while the fact that we lag behind other industrialized countries does concern me, I'm curious about what your solution is. Do you really think eliminating the public school system entirely would make things better?
Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:21 (UTC)Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:40 (UTC)I don't know. I've known some very good private schools. I've also known some (like some of the religious white-flight schools I saw crop up in the south in the wake of integration), that were substandard, especially when it came to science. In any event it's not a fair comparison because private schools, unlike public schools, have the option of refusing to accept students with serious cognitive or behavioral problems.
I've answered your question, so please answer my question. Do you think eliminating the public schools entirely would make things better?
Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:42 (UTC)Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:49 (UTC)Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:52 (UTC)Re: If you're serious...
Date: 17/7/11 02:03 (UTC)From your third link:
We hit 2.2% right after public schools started outnumbering private ones, before things went downhill by WWII, presumably recovered, and then went downhill again recently. Which would suggest institutional reform is the solution, rather than gutting the public education system altogether.
Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 21:55 (UTC)Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:17 (UTC)Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:50 (UTC)Re: If you're serious...
Date: 17/7/11 15:13 (UTC)Very revealing, that.
Re: If you're serious...
Date: 16/7/11 22:54 (UTC)Re: If you're serious...
Date: 17/7/11 22:43 (UTC)Are the Japanese schools public or private?